ARTICLE 311

Copyright infringement not intended

Picture Courtesy: https://epaper.thehindu.com/ccidist-ws/th/th_delhi/issues/93696/OPS/G4KD5AQDG.1+G3FD5ARP1.1.html

 

Context: On August 3, 2024, the Lieutenant Governor of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) used Article 311 of the Indian Constitution to fire six government employees who were allegedly involved in activities harmful to the state.

 About Article 311

• Article 311 of the Indian Constitution deals with the protection of civil servants in India.
• It ensures that no civil servant can be dismissed, removed, or demoted without proper procedures being followed.
• The article provides a framework to safeguard the rights of those employed in civil capacities under the Union or State governments.
  

Evolution of the Article 311 ●Introduction: Article 311 was introduced by the Drafting Committee of the Indian Constitution. ●Draft Discussion: During discussions, members proposed various changes, including transferring dismissal powers to the Public Service Commission to ensure bureaucratic independence. However, these suggestions were not accepted. ●Concerns: Some members felt that the grounds for denying an opportunity to be heard were too broad, potentially undermining civil servants' protections. ●Clarifications: It was clarified that Parliament and State legislatures could make laws regarding dismissal procedures, and appeals could be made to the Public Service Commission if the opportunity to be heard was denied. ●Amendment: In 1976, Article 311 was amended to clarify that if a penalty is imposed after a hearing, there is no need for a separate hearing to determine the penalty amount.

 Key Provisions of the Article 311

• Authority for Dismissal or Removal:
  • • Clause (1): A civil servant cannot be dismissed or removed by an authority lower than the one that appointed them. This means that if they were appointed by a high-ranking official, only that official or a higher authority can dismiss them.
• Inquiry and Opportunity to be Heard:
  • • Clause (2): Before dismissing, removing, or demoting a civil servant, the person must be given:
    • Information about the charges against them.
    • A chance to present their side of the story regarding these charges.
    • However, there are exceptions to this rule:
    • Criminal Conviction: If the dismissal or demotion is due to the person’s conviction of a criminal offence, the procedure of inquiry may not apply.
    • Practical Impossibility: If it is not feasible to hold an inquiry, the authority must record the reasons in writing.
    • Security Reasons: If holding an inquiry is deemed not in the interest of State security, the procedure can be bypassed.
    • Decision on Practicality:
    • Clause (3): If there is a dispute about whether it is practical to hold an inquiry, the decision of the authority on this matter is final.

 Indian Civil Services

• The Indian Civil Services represent the backbone of the country's permanent executive branch.
• They consist of civil servants who manage and administer government functions across central and state levels. This structure ensures continuity and stability in governance.
• Appointments to All India Civil Services are made by the President of India, which includes the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), and Indian Forest Service (IFS).
• Members of these services are chosen by the Union government and serve under both State and Centre cadres.
• As per Article 310, members of the defence services, civil services of the Centre, and all-India services hold office at the pleasure of the President, while members of state civil services hold office at the pleasure of the state governor.
• Safeguards under Article 311 protect civil servants from arbitrary dismissal by ensuring they cannot be removed without an inquiry and a chance to defend themselves.

Historical Context The Indian Civil Service has evolved significantly from its origins during British rule. Warren Hastings laid its foundation, and Charles Cornwallis reformed and modernized it. Cornwallis is often credited as the 'Father of Civil Service in India.' He introduced two divisions: The covenanted (for Europeans) and uncovenanted (for Indians at lower levels). This system was a precursor to today's structure. The Government of India Act 1919 split the Imperial Services into All India Services and Central Services. By 1924, these services were known as Central Superior Services, overseeing various administrative functions. The modern Indian Civil Service system was established post-independence in 1947, with a focus on national unity and integrity.

 Constitutional Basis

• Article 312 of the Indian Constitution allows the Rajya Sabha (upper house of Parliament) to create new branches of the All India Services with a two-thirds majority. This provision led to the establishment of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), and Indian Forest Service (IFoS).

Guiding Principles and Code of Ethics

Civil servants are expected to uphold values such as integrity, loyalty to the Constitution, patriotism, honesty, and impartiality. They must:

• Perform duties with responsibility and accountability.
• Avoid misuse of their position.
• Serve as instruments of good governance and social development.

Roles and Responsibilities

Civil servants manage various central and state government functions. They work in areas like:

• Administration
• Diplomacy
• Tax collection
• Law enforcement
• Public sector enterprises

Head of Civil Services

• The highest-ranking civil servant is the Cabinet Secretary. This role oversees the Indian Administrative Service and other civil services, ensuring they are well-equipped and operate effectively.
• The Cabinet Secretary also holds a high position in the Order of Precedence.

Promotions and Appointments

• Promotions to higher ranks are managed by the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet, while lower-level promotions are handled by the Civil Services Board.

Dispute Resolution

• The Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) resolves disputes involving civil servants, such as unfair dismissal or corruption allegations.

Civil Service Day marked on April 21 commemorates Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's address to Administrative Services Officers in 1947.

Conclusion

• Article 311 ensures that civil servants have protection against arbitrary dismissal or demotion. It establishes that such actions must be taken by the appointing authority or higher and that the person involved must be given a chance to respond to charges. Exceptions apply in cases of criminal conviction, practical difficulties, or security concerns. The article reflects a balance between administrative efficiency and the protection of civil servants' rights.

 Must Read Articles:

NATIONAL CIVIL SERVICES DAY

Source:

THE HINDU

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA

PRACTICE QUESTION Q. Analyze the role of civil servants in maintaining the integrity and effectiveness of democratic institutions in India. What measures are in place to ensure that civil servants remain unbiased and free from political influence?